Skip to Content. Skip to Navigation.

Our Say

 
 

Private ownership ruining the EPL

13/09/2008 8:15 AM

Recent events have highlighted the best and the worst of the private ownership divide that now dominates the English Premier League.

On the one hand Manchester City - the lovable losers of English Football whose last trophy was way back in 1976 - are suddenly dreaming of ending the dominance of the England's big four of their fierce local rivals Manchester United, Liverpool, Chelsea and Arsenal.

And on the other hand West Ham and Newcastle - which like Man City are traditionally big clubs that have fallen further and further behind the big four as the years progress - have just had a reminder of how wealthy private ownership is not all it's cracked up to be.

First Manchester City - the club which has just been bought by Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed al-Nahyan - the brother of the ruler of Dubai in the oil-rich United Arab Emirates and a man whose wealth even dwarves that of Chelsea's mega-rich Russian owner Roman Abramovich.

Abramovich of course has single-handedly bankrolled Chelsea into one of England's and Europe's top clubs - without a care in the world for the bottom line - as the Blues ended a 50 year title drought by winning the EPL crown in 2005 and 2006 before finishing runner-up to United for the past two seasons as well as finishing runner-up again to United in the European Champions' League last season.

Chelsea showed that with enough money - and most importantly with the right manager in the since-departed Jose Mourinho - that any club could take on and indeed defeat the traditional three powerhouses of English football in Liverpool, United and Arsenal.
Now Man City is set to follow that blueprint and have already secured Brazilian superstar Robinho for a British record transfer fee of £32.5million or nearly $A70 million from Real Madrid.

And now City is throwing unheard of sums at players such as United's superstar winger Cristiano Ronaldo and former United striker Ruud Van Nistelrooy.

The fact that City were even able to outbid mega-rich Chelsea for Robinho signals a major power switch in the EPL and sends a strong message to the big four that they may no longer be able to take their places in the top four each season - which guarantees them the continual riches that come with participation in the Champions' League which in turn keeps them ahead of their less well-heeled rivals - for granted.

But what kind of message does it send to the other 80 odd clubs that make up England's four division professional structure that the only way of breaking into the big four is to have one of the world's richest men take over the club.

However private ownership is certainly not working for all clubs - particularly those whose private owners don't have a bottomless pit of money and actually seek to try to balance the books at some point, as most responsible businesses (as football clearly is these days) have to do.

Newcastle - which like Man City has struggled for decades despite its enormous supporter base - thought they had a winner when wealthy sports store owner and life-long fan Mike Ashley took over the club.

And his stocks only rose when one of his first actions was to dump Sam Allardyce as manager and replace him with Newcastle hero Kevin Keegan.

But now less than a year later Keegan wants to leave - frustrated at Newcastle's recruiting policy and his lack of opportunity to go out and strengthen a mediocre Magpies' squad capable of competing with the big four and now Man City.

And now West Ham's manager Alan Curbishley - one of the most respected club bosses in English football - has quit the club where his career began way back in 1974 after the club's Icelandic owners began selling his players without his approval, again to balance the books.

So suddenly the Hammers - the club which has probably produced more of its own star players (that are regularly poached by richer clubs) over the years than any other club - again faces an uncertain future.

But what does it say about the state of the EPL where your chances of success solely depend on how wealthy your private owner is.

Right now Man City fans must be pinching themselves and dreaming of not just usurping United but even maybe becoming European Champions down the track while Newcastle and Hammers' fans not to mention fans of other big clubs such as Tottenham, Villa and Everton - which are also desperately trying to end the dominance of the big four - are jealously hoping some oil-rich Sheikh or Russian businessman will buy their clubs.

And as for fans of truly battling EPL clubs such Middlesbrough, Wigan, Hull, West Brom and Stoke - they know such dreams will never come true and for them just being in the EPL is a win in itself.

But all this adds up to is a competition that is becoming less interesting by the year and it is no wonder so many football fans - not just in Australia but in England - are beginning to turn their attentions to the country's second-tier competition - The Championship - where money and private ownership has yet to corrupt the game.

 

Latest Headlines

 
 
Reds aim high for Jets
Reds aim high for Jets
Football
08/01/2009 1:27 PM
A 'flat' Adelaide United is optimistic it can shake off the lethargy it displayed against ...
 
 
Griffin to master No.1 spot
Football
08/01/2009 4:10 PM
 
Jets happy with ACL draw
Football
08/01/2009 11:32 AM
 
Rams stun United
Football
08/01/2009 9:41 AM
 
Mariners make use of English connections
Football
08/01/2009 9:13 AM
 
Motherwell sinks Hearts
Football
08/01/2009 9:13 AM
 
Terry rues Bridge sale
Football
08/01/2009 5:31 AM
 
Jets handed good draw
Football
07/01/2009 7:02 PM
 
Farina wants five more
Football
07/01/2009 4:34 PM
 
Glory out to impress
Football
07/01/2009 4:13 PM
 
 
 

Your Say

 
 

Our Say

 
 
Melbourne looking the goods
Melbourne looking the goods
Bren O'Brien
Aurelio Vidmar will be having a few sleepless nights in the lead-up to the finals trying ...more
United's busy schedule a worry
United's busy schedule a worry
Paul Gough
Manchester United's participation in the 'Mickey Mouse' FIFA World Club Championship ...more