Skip to Content. Skip to Navigation.
Advertisement
AFL

News

Mick queries Teddy

Mick queries Teddy

11/29/2011 01:52:59 AM

Western Bulldogs president David Smorgon has hit out at Mick Malthouse for questioning whether Ted Whitten is a legend of the game.

Malthouse was speaking on 3AW on Tuesday morning where he, in an almost stream-of-consciousness fashion, queried whether Whitten should be considered a legend alongside the likes of Ron Barassi and Jock McHale.

Malthouse should probably prepare for a social media storm of disapproval from Bulldogs' fans after the club immediately took to Twitter to question the former Collingwood, West Coast and Footscray coach's comments, while also asking fans to vent their spleen against him on a Facebook page put up entirely for that purpose.

"I go around the MCG every now and again and have a look at some of the statues that are up there and I think they are legends," said Malthouse on 3AW.

"There's Barassi and others. Teddy Whitten, I don't know if Teddy Whitten is a legend but certainly Barassi is."

"Legend status is quite extraordinary and I think Teddy may well be a legend, I'm not too sure, but certainly Barassi and Jock McHale and Leigh Matthews, these sort of blokes, Kevin Bartlett probably should be if he's not."

"(He was) a good player, good player, but I'm just wondering whether he played enough games and did he play in premierships and so."

"He probably did play in the premiership in '54," Malthouse finally said. "He may of. Perhaps he should be a legend."

According to the AFL, Whitten, who passed away in 1995 at the age of 62, is categorically a legend, having been given that status after being one of the first inductees into the Hall of Fame in 1996.

Overall, in a career that went from 1951 to 1970, Whitten played in 321 matches, 10 of which were finals, including the club's only premiership in 1954.

He was also one of three Australian rules footballers recognised as a Legend of Australian Sport by the Sport Australia Hall of Fame, alongside Barassi and Matthews.

Malthouse to his credit tweeted soon after:

"My association w EJ Whitten was 1stclass.He was & always will be a legend of a bloke & of the game. No disrespect intended."

Smorgon, though, was initially left dumbfounded by the comments, although he said he gladly accepted Malthouse's latter tweet.

"I can't ever recall anyone attacking Ted Whitten's status as a legend of the game," said Smorgon initially, through the Bulldogs Twitter account on Tuesday morning.

"Ted's record is exemplary and I am extremely disappointed that Mick, who coached the Bulldogs in the mid-eighties, has questioned the status of one of our game's greats."

Malthouse didn't stop there, though, as he discussed his recent trip to Switzerland and Belgium.

"Probably Switzerland spoiled Belgium," he said.

"The Swiss, I've always been intrigued why people can make things happen and the Swiss with their watches, no wonder they've been going for a 100 odd years and you think, why are they still renowned for their precision?"

"(But) they're quite anal, the Swiss, it's only half the size of Tasmania, the people aren't exactly overly friendly but that's just their method, that's just their mannerism more so than being rude and every photograph taken is picture perfect."

"I went to Belgium after that and I found that Bruges is outstanding but really it's quite dull, grey, not exactly the cleanest place on earth and coming back to Melbourne you just realise how great Melbourne is," he said.

 
Photograph Copyright : Getty Images

You Might Also Like

Cooney ruled out for Darwin trek
Cooney ruled out for Darwin trek
05/15/2012 02:38:18 AM
Western Bulldogs will be without star midfielder Adam Cooney for another week after he was ruled out of Saturday night's match against Gold ...
 
 
Dreams coming true for Dickson
05/14/2012 05:34:57 AM
 
Dogs upset poor Kangaroos
05/13/2012 06:08:14 AM
 
Bulldogs lose Cooney
05/13/2012 02:42:14 AM
 
Morris suffers leg setback
05/08/2012 07:06:37 AM
 
McCartney: Dogs went down fighting
05/04/2012 09:15:21 PM
 
Pies down gutsy Bulldogs
05/04/2012 12:46:05 PM
 
Jolly out of Dogs clash
05/04/2012 08:44:46 AM
 
 
 

Most Read Articles

Is this the true AFL Ladder?
Is this the true AFL Ladder?
AFL
05/16/2012 03:30:17 AM
Take a look at what the AFL ladder would look like if games against the bottom three ...
 
 
Adelaide United snare win in Japan
Football
05/16/2012 11:19:39 AM
 
Five suspended in IPL spot-fixing saga
Cricket
05/15/2012 06:36:38 PM
 
Eagles' injury crisis easing
AFL
05/16/2012 03:12:17 AM
 
Victory part ways with Hernandez
Football
05/16/2012 07:30:19 AM
 
McLaren lend support to Williams
Motorsport
05/15/2012 09:37:19 PM
 
Kelly: No rift with Scott
AFL
05/16/2012 01:28:21 AM
 
Phelps to retire after London Olympics
Other Sports
05/15/2012 06:45:06 PM
 
 
 

Fantasy AFL: Best Players

Our Say

Is this the true AFL Ladder?
Is this the true AFL Ladder?
Bren O'Brien
Take a look at what the AFL ladder would look like if games against the bottom three ...more
Crackers' Call: Same old story for Roos
Crackers' Call: Same old story for Roos
Peter 'Crackers' Keenan
I'm a life member of North Melbourne footy club and I've enjoyed my association with the ...more
 
Poll
Which NRL club is hit the hardest by Origin?