Skip to Content. Skip to Navigation.
Advertisement
AFL

News

Knights saga an embarrassment

08/29/2010 09:04:16 AM

Essendon's handling of Matthew Knights' sacking was nothing short of an embarrassment for all parties involved.

Chairman Mark Evans and CEO Ian Robson confirmed that Knights' three-year tenure at the club was over on Sunday evening, less than 24 hours after the Bombers' season ended following their 29-point loss to the Western Bulldogs on Saturday night.

The quickfire decision reeks of desperation as the club looks to appease the growing unrest among the Essendon fans and members.

When Knights was appointed coach at the end of the 2007 season, he faced a near-impossible task of following in the footsteps of the club's greatest ever coach, Kevin Sheedy.

In his three years in the job, Knights has always favoured youth over experience and continually looked to the future development of his young charges. He also employed a game plan which encouraged his players to run and attack.

In his second year in charge he led the new generation of baby Bombers to an unlikely finals berth. They would ultimately get thrashed by the Crows in an elimination final in Adelaide, but the signs were there that the future was bright at Windy Hill.

The Essendon board agreed and immediately re-signed Knights for a further two years, taking him until the end of the 2012 season.

The Bombers started this season with just one win from their first five matches, however they turned that around to square their win-loss record at 5-5 with big wins over top-four sides St Kilda and Western Bulldogs on the way.

A six-game losing streak followed and the pressure began to build around Knights, although you would never know it based on the way he portrayed himself in front of the media as he always remained confident he was the right man to lead the club.

He always talked fondly of his close relationship with Evans and Robson and said that he had no reason to believe that he wouldn't be coaching the club in 2011 season.

It is not clear when the decision was made to sack Knights but it's unlikely that it was on Sunday morning and it seems that 39-year-old has been a dead-man walking for a number of weeks now.

Yes there is no doubting the Bombers underachieved this year, but with an average age of just 22.7 (11th in the AFL) and an average of just 44.7 games per player (13th) is there any wonder why they missed out on the finals?

You have to feel for Knights as he was forced to put on a brave face week after week, while all the time he was left in the dark on his future.

But it is the club who has egg on their face now as they have to pay out Knights an estimated $800,000 for the remainder of his contract.

 
Comments
Posted by John Blades at
29/08/2010 10:23 PM
It is truly an appropriate decision to sack Knights. Although I don't even support the club(go pies in September), it was so transparent that he masqueraded as an AFL coach delivering phoney posture at press conferences and staring at umpires, whilst failing to gain the respect and inspiration from his playing group. What madness it was to force Lloyd out of the game. I don't blame members and supporters of the Essendon football club being so disgruntled and disgusted with Knights. How he ever got the coaching job in the first place is still a mystery, but remember, this was the bloke who said while playing for Richmond "I want to be captain". Honestly, true leaders and champions earn positions of responsibility. As I said earlier, how he ever got the coaching job in the first place is still a mystery. I truly hope Essendon finds its feet with a new coaching regime and Anzac day becomes the huge contest it always was. John, Mount Martha
Posted by Eric, Semaphore SA at
30/08/2010 08:12 AM
After watching his very ordinary one year stint with the Port Magpies in the SANFL, I formed the opinion that he couldn't coach pigs in mud. It didn't surprise me that he has fallen well short at AFL level, but after appointing him in the first place, extending his contract, and then sacking him with two full years left on his contract (that must be close to a record?), it looks VERY ordinary from the Essendon Football Club!

You Might Also Like

Freo bring back tall timber
Freo bring back tall timber
05/25/2012 07:11:24 AM
Fremantle have called on the tall timber for Sunday's Western Derby against West Coast with ruckman Jon Griffin and key defender Alex ...
 
 
AFL Teams - Round 9
05/25/2012 07:09:25 AM
 
Clarkson: Midfield battle key
05/25/2012 05:19:18 AM
 
Watters wants ruck ownership
05/25/2012 03:58:57 AM
 
Port look to maintain Power
05/25/2012 02:21:52 AM
 
Hird: No romance in Sheedy clash
05/25/2012 01:32:05 AM
 
Lyon shrugs off Ballantyne slump
05/25/2012 12:34:55 AM
 
Bastinac stays with North
05/24/2012 11:08:39 PM
 
 
 

Most Read Articles

Toovey: T-Rex will miss Origin II
Toovey: T-Rex will miss Origin II
League
05/25/2012 01:01:22 AM
Manly coach Geoff Toovey has confirmed game-breaking forward Tony Williams is likely to ...
 
 
AFL Teams - Round 9
AFL
05/25/2012 07:09:25 AM
 
Harrigan denies Stuart claim
League
05/24/2012 08:43:59 AM
 
Meares spearheads cycling team
Other Sports
05/25/2012 05:35:29 AM
 
AFL Teams - Round 9
AFL
05/24/2012 08:39:31 AM
 
Lima signs for Rabbitohs
League
05/25/2012 02:45:35 AM
 
Freo bring back tall timber
AFL
05/25/2012 07:11:24 AM
 
Drogba void concerns Lampard
Football
05/24/2012 11:18:59 AM
 
 
 

Fantasy AFL: Best Players

Our Say

Interstate sides back on top
Interstate sides back on top
Luke Sheehan
The AFL cycle has come full circle once more - that is, to say, the non-Victorian sides ...more
Crackers' Call: Dees sinking further
Crackers' Call: Dees sinking further
Peter 'Crackers' Keenan
It's probably time to put the boots into Melbourne again because, quite simply, they're a ...more
 
Poll
Should Greg Inglis' match-winning try been awarded in Origin I?