Skip to Content. Skip to Navigation.
Advertisement
AFL

News

Daw's flaws expose old prejudices

02/09/2012 12:36:14 AM

If the ludicrous overreaction to North Melbourne's decision to suspend rookie Majak Daw is any guide of the tenor of AFL coverage this season then we are in for another ride on the excrement-fuelled rollercoaster that is the AFL media circus.

To put the Daw story in its proper context, this was a story about a player who has yet to make his AFL debut (there are probably over 200 in this category at the moment) doing the wrong thing by the club in terms of his rehabilitation from a knee injury, failing to tell the truth and the club suspending him for that breach.

It is something that would happen around 10 times a year across the AFL as in particular young players, struggle to meet the expectations set for them by the clubs. As a story in-season it would battle to make it beyond the 'In Brief' section, or as a tack-on to the end of its story.

It was the exotic nature of the subject which made it apparently newsworthy and that says more about the falsehood of the AFL industry's supposedly learned approach to cultural engagement than anything else.

Should he make it to an AFL debut, Daw would become the first Sudanese-born footballer to play Australia's indigenous sport at the highest level.

His arrival on the scene was hailed as a victory for the globalisation of the sport and its ability to transcend culture. He quickly became the AFL's poster boy for a generation of African migrants many of whom had initially struggled to adapt to their new surrounds.

Despite the fact he was still a long way from being ready for senior football, both the AFL and North Melbourne, a club seriously short of star power, were happy to put him up as representing something more than a kid from a disadvantaged background working hard to create a professional sporting career.

There was something a little colonial about the way that his body shape and athleticism were being appraised in the manner of a 19th century explorer on the prowl in the 'dark continent' for museum specimens.

His name added to his mystical quality and he became the most famous rookie in the AFL. His notoriety was advanced by an ugly incident at a VFL match last year where he was repeatedly racially abused.

'Tut-tut' said the educated masses. But while their motives were much more pure, there has always been an element of race in the fascination with Daw.

It is a similar story with the 'fascination' in which the skills of indigenous players are held. The concept of 'magic' still pervades in perceptions of the roughly 10 percent of players of Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander background in the AFL. Coupled with that are less flattering characteristics of 'unreliability' or 'inconsistency.'

We may no longer abuse players directly by the colour of their skin, but while we are still judging their skills in the context of their cultural background, there is still a racial element in our assessment.

The long history of Aboriginal involvement in AFL - plus the massive strides made in racial relations in the sport in the 1990s - has helped ensure that the 70-80 players indigenous currently on AFL list have a strong support network.

Daw has not been afforded that in his very public development as a player. Now he finds himself on the front page of Australia's highest selling newspaper, shirtless, next to a racy photo of what is apparently his girlfriend, who apparently some time ago used to be involved with someone who used to be an AFL footballer, alongside allegations that he owes a couple of his team-mates money.

For the readership of the Herald-Sun it fits a racial profile very nicely. Other media outlets were no-where near as overt, but all of them, including the new regime at the AFL website, sought to give this story significant prominence.

But perhaps the great insult, not just to Daw, or his club, or all our intelligence, is that two of the biggest names in football journalism in this town which is utterly obsessed by this game, saw fit to blame the club for the fact that the rumour mill had gone into overdrive.

'If only they'd told the truth from the start' opined Caroline Wilson and Mark Robinson.

If only this had occurred to some other poor soul, we wouldn't have heard a thing and the underbelly of old football and cultural prejudices might have not been exposed.

Football's a much fairer and better game when it's played out on the field.

 
Photograph Copyright : Getty Images
Comments
Posted by Hen Bopper at
09/02/2012 05:37 PM
Excellent article - an inconvenient truth to many no doubt.
Posted by James P at
10/02/2012 08:32 AM
ah thank god there is media out there like this! the herald sun will build a person up but cut them down the second they make one mistake, front page news? what a joke! Majak will be a champion! Go Roos.
Posted by Jake at
10/02/2012 08:51 AM
Best I have read for ages. Thankyou for hitting the nail on the head.
Posted by Desert Hawk at
10/02/2012 12:03 PM
Great observations! Always cringe slightly when I hear 'magic' on any commentary. I especially liked; "We may no longer abuse players directly by the colour of their skin, but while we are still judging their skills in the context of their cultural background, there is still a racial element in our assessment."
Posted by Lyle at
11/02/2012 01:58 PM
Bren you will not realise how much I agree with this and wish THIS article was on the front page of the HS - i commented to Mark R (a fellow Geelong supporter) how much I was disusted in his column which shows his racial prejudice. I did not read CWs but imagine it was the same. North took into consideration this young mans background and gave the media only what it needed to know but like gutter-rats they HAD to fish for more which was none of their damn business, and then blew the story out of proportion to make news. Thank you again for a great article.
Posted by Toddy at
11/02/2012 05:34 PM
I cannot agree more with these comments and the article - especially the point about the publicity mill ! If the lad has problems it would be easier for HIM to sort it out with the help of his club (which is what most clubs do !) , without this being trumpetted in the media ! Good Luck to anyone else who wants to try to make it in AFL from a different background , this would really encourage you to try ....NOT !
Posted by Emgee at
12/02/2012 09:17 AM
Couldn't agree more. I love sport and AFL especially but I really think we have to grow up a bit and afford indigenous and dare I say it non-caucasian players the same level of respect. We are so quick to raise up and just as quick to cut down. Let us afford this young man (Daw) the opportunity to grow up, play football and be human.
Posted by Hammer at
16/02/2012 04:34 PM
Well said, the media in Australia is out of control.

You Might Also Like

Cat Menzel says no to Adelaide
Cat Menzel says no to Adelaide
05/17/2012 01:06:34 AM
Injured Geelong forward Daniel Menzel has put pen to paper on a new deal to stay with the Cats, ending speculation he would be traded back ...
 
 
Award to commemorate Stynes
05/16/2012 05:55:40 AM
 
Scott to wield axe at North
05/16/2012 04:24:28 AM
 
Eagles' injury crisis easing
05/16/2012 03:12:17 AM
 
Kelly: No rift with Scott
05/16/2012 01:28:21 AM
 
Osborne opts for traditional surgery
05/15/2012 10:05:19 AM
 
Pies want payback against Cats
05/15/2012 07:32:55 AM
 
Another blow for Winderlich
05/15/2012 03:59:01 AM
 
 
 

Most Read Articles

Is this the true AFL Ladder?
Is this the true AFL Ladder?
AFL
05/16/2012 03:30:17 AM
Take a look at what the AFL ladder would look like if games against the bottom three ...
 
 
Ex-F1 driver turns to V8s
Motorsport
05/17/2012 12:26:09 AM
 
Dalglish sacked as Liverpool manager
Football
05/16/2012 07:25:03 PM
 
Popovic to coach new Sydney team
Football
05/16/2012 09:45:34 PM
 
Galekovic hell-bent on ACL glory
Football
05/17/2012 12:37:28 AM
 
Modric hints at Tottenham exit
Football
05/16/2012 06:54:04 PM
 
Cat Menzel says no to Adelaide
AFL
05/17/2012 01:06:34 AM
 
Adelaide United snare win in Japan
Football
05/16/2012 11:19:39 AM
 
 
 

Fantasy AFL: Best Players

Our Say

Is this the true AFL Ladder?
Is this the true AFL Ladder?
Bren O'Brien
Take a look at what the AFL ladder would look like if games against the bottom three ...more
Crackers' Call: Same old story for Roos
Crackers' Call: Same old story for Roos
Peter 'Crackers' Keenan
I'm a life member of North Melbourne footy club and I've enjoyed my association with the ...more
 
Poll
Which NRL club is hit the hardest by Origin?