Skip to Content. Skip to Navigation.
Advertisement
AFL

News

Cats' reign to end?

Cats' reign to end?

03/18/2010 05:23:41 AM

Geelong's reign as the undisputed kings of the AFL is about to come to an end.

At least that was the view of the AFL captains on Thursday in their annual poll on the eve of the season as the game's leaders instead nominated last year's runners-up St Kilda and NAB Cup champions and beaten preliminary finalists of the past two years in the Western Bulldogs as the teams to beat in season 2010.

The 16 club captains gave their answers to a series of questions on the grounds of confidentiality with the most surprising response coming when they were asked - 'Which other club (besides your own) is most likely to reach the Grand Final.'

While the Cats - who have won two of the past three premierships and a total of 65 out of 75 matches during that time - have been the universal choice of virtually every captain in the past couple of seasons to reach the grand final, this year only three rival captains tipped the Cats' to reach their fourth successive premiership decider.

In contrast the Saints and the Bulldogs - the two teams with the longest premiership droughts in the competition - attracted six votes each from the rival skippers while the other vote went to Collingwood, the other beaten preliminary finalist from last year.

And when asked which seven other clubs would feature in the top eight this year, one captain even tipped the Cats to miss the eight with only Collingwood, St Kilda and the Bulldogs attracting the votes of all 15 rival captains to play in the finals this year while Brisbane and Geelong attracted 14 of a possible 15 votes.

Other teams widely tipped to make the finals were Adelaide - with 13 of the rival 15 skippers tipping them to make the eight - and 2008 premiers Hawthorn, which attracted 12 votes.

The eighth spot is seen as wide open by the captains with Port Adelaide - five votes - attracting the next highest support while Fremantle, Richmond and Melbourne were the only clubs that were not tipped to make the finals in 2010 by a single rival captain.

On the individual front, the Brownlow Medal is tipped as being wide open with 11 different players nominated by the 16 captains as their choice to win the award.

Geelong's reigning winner Gary Ablett won the most support with three votes while teammate Joel Selwood, St Kilda star Nick Dal Santo and Carlton skipper and 2004 winner Chris Judd received two votes each while the Bulldogs' boom recruit Barry Hall was even tipped by one captain to win the Brownlow.
Hall, who dominated the NAB Cup for the Bulldogs in kicking 17 goals in three matches including seven in the grand final win over St Kilda when he won the Michael Tuck Medal for best afield, was also tipped by four captains to win this year's Coleman Medal.

Former Carlton bad boy and now Brisbane spearhead Brendan Fevola was tipped by five captains to win the Coleman while Hawthorn superstar Lance Franklin was the top choice of four skippers to be this year's leading goalkicker.

And as for the Rising Star of 2010, West Coast's exciting young ruckman Nic Naitanui and North Melbourne midfielder Jack Ziebell were the top choices attracting five votes each from the skippers.

 

You Might Also Like

Pies turn to kids in absence of stars
Pies turn to kids in absence of stars
05/24/2012 09:44:38 AM
Jamie Elliot and Marley Williams will make their Collingwood debuts against the Crows on Saturday, while Geelong welcome back Matthew ...
 
 
Hayes still hungry for flag
05/23/2012 04:32:28 AM
 
Saints face rucking hell
05/22/2012 06:52:28 AM
 
Scarlett may miss again for Cats
05/22/2012 03:18:25 AM
 
Pies depth set to be tested
05/22/2012 02:35:11 AM
 
Blow for injured Pies duo
05/21/2012 07:02:00 AM
 
Watters: Six-day break no excuse
05/20/2012 09:23:16 PM
 
Eagles hold off gallant Saints
05/20/2012 09:29:22 AM
 
 
 

Most Read Articles

Harrigan denies Stuart claim
Harrigan denies Stuart claim
League
05/24/2012 08:43:59 AM
Referees boss Bill Harrigan denies admitting the controversial Greg Inglis try should not ...
 
 
Drogba void concerns Lampard
Football
05/24/2012 11:18:59 AM
 
AFL Teams - Round 9
AFL
05/24/2012 08:39:31 AM
 
Stuart's silence the real controversy
League
05/24/2012 06:40:00 AM
 
Tigers set to turn to youngster
AFL
05/24/2012 04:05:15 AM
 
Barton banned for 12 matches
Football
05/23/2012 11:04:50 PM
 
Meninga praises Queensland character
League
05/24/2012 02:22:09 AM
 
Inglis sticks by try ruling
League
05/24/2012 06:55:53 AM
 
 
 

Fantasy AFL: Best Players

Our Say

Interstate sides back on top
Interstate sides back on top
Luke Sheehan
The AFL cycle has come full circle once more - that is, to say, the non-Victorian sides ...more
Crackers' Call: Dees sinking further
Crackers' Call: Dees sinking further
Peter 'Crackers' Keenan
It's probably time to put the boots into Melbourne again because, quite simply, they're a ...more
 
Poll
Should Greg Inglis' match-winning try been awarded in Origin I?